Do You Really Need Test Prep for the SAT or ACT?

Test prep is one of the most common questions families ask during the college admissions process.

Should we hire a tutor?
Can our student prepare independently?
Does test prep actually make a difference?

The honest answer is: it depends.

Can Students Prep on Their Own?

There are more free and affordable resources available today than ever before. Many motivated students can successfully prepare on their own using:

• Practice test books

• Online resources

• Released exams

• Khan Academy (for SAT prep)

However, self-prep requires accountability. Students must consistently practice, complete assignments, and track progress. The reality is simple: you get out of test prep what you put into it.

When Does Hiring a Tutor Make Sense?

For some students, outside structure and accountability make a significant difference.

Before investing, families should consider:

• Does your student stay motivated independently?

• Do they benefit from one-on-one instruction?

• Would a classroom setting be helpful or distracting?

• Is virtual learning effective for them, or do they need in-person support?

There is no universally “best” format. The best format is the one that matches your child’s learning style.

Sometimes even small adjustments — like shortening session lengths — can improve engagement and results.

Does Test Prep Actually Improve Scores?

Yes, it can.

Standardized tests are coachable. With targeted practice, some students do see meaningful increases in their scores.

That said, test prep is not mandatory. It is simply one strategic tool among many in the admissions process. Families must weigh the time, financial investment, and potential benefit.

What About Test-Optional Colleges?

The testing landscape continues to evolve. Many schools remain test optional, while others are returning to requiring standardized testing.

Because policies vary — and can change — our general guidance has been for students to proceed as though testing may be needed somewhere in the process, especially during junior year.

From there, decisions can be made strategically.

The Bottom Line

There is no single right answer about test prep.

The right decision depends on:

• Your student’s motivation

• Their learning style

• Your family’s priorities

• The types of schools on their list

As with most parts of the college process, individualized planning is key.

If you have questions about testing strategy or would like recommendations for test prep providers, we’re happy to help.

Book a Free Call or join our College Prep Club.